2 min read

Tasking carpenter with work outside skillset results in tragic fall from height

A commercial construction company was fined $150,000 after the unsafe removal of a tree at its Carrum Downs site left a carpenter a paraplegic following a fall from height. 

Background

IntraAust Properties Pty Ltd was the principal contractor for a construction project on a Carrum Downs site. It engaged several labour hire workers at the site, including an experienced and qualified carpenter.

In March 2024, to allow a concrete truck access for a concrete pour, the company required a large gum tree branch to be removed. The branch was approximately 4.5 metres above ground, 6 metres long and 20 centimetres in diameter. 

The day before the task was scheduled, the company’s supervisor, who was also the site’s health and safety representative, discussed with the carpenter how the concrete truck would access the slab-pouring area. It was decided that the carpenter would bring his chainsaw to the workplace to remove the branch.

The carpenter told the supervisor that he had experience cutting tree branches near his home, but was not a qualified arborist or tree-removal specialist. They did not discuss how the carpenter would reach the branch or the safety risks associated with removing it. Additionally, the supervisor did not prepare a safe work method statement for the task, nor was a temporary or elevated work platform provided for the carpenter to use.

Incident

On the day of the incident, the carpenter set up a 3.7-metre A-frame ladder and attempted to perform the task using a chainsaw while standing high up on the ladder. Performing the task this way meant there was a risk of serious injury or death including by being struck by a tree branch (or a part of it) and/or falling from height. 

As the carpenter was cutting the branch into sections, one branch swung down and struck the ladder, causing him to be knocked off and fall head first to the ground. He suffered a spinal column dislocation as a result, which left him a paraplegic confined to a wheelchair. 

Judgment

The company pleaded guilty to failing to reduce the risk, so far as was reasonably practicable, by providing or maintaining systems of work.

In sentencing the company, the Court noted that it had failed to take simple remedial steps to reduce the risk of falling from height by:

  • engaging a qualified arborist or tree-removal specialist to perform the task; or
  • providing a temporary work platform, such as an elevating work platform, for the carpenter to use to perform the task; or
  • providing a telescopic long chainsaw for the carpenter to use while performing the task.

The company was sentenced, with conviction, to pay a fine of $150,000 and costs of $13,335. Without the plea of guilty, the company would have been sentenced to a fine of $220,000.


latest Workplace bulletin
CTA Image

Payday Super may result in nasty tax surprise for salary package professionals
Since 1 July 2026, Payday Super has required employers to pay superannuation guarantee contributions within 7 business days of employees receiving qualifying earnings ...

Read more

upload in progress, 0
Subscribe to the Health & Safety Bulletin

From the experts behind the Health & Safety Handbook, the Bulletin brings you the latest work health and safety news, legal updates, case law and practical advice straight to your inbox every week.

Sending confirmation email...
Great! Now check your inbox and click the link to confirm your subscription.
Please enter a valid email address!