3 min read

Power of 3: How to put workers at risk of electrocution

An NSW construction company was fined $238,000 after one of its workers suffered an electric shock when a 16-metre-long reinforcement cage fell onto two 11,000-volt powerlines (SafeWork NSW v Civil 1 Pty Ltd [2026]).

Background

Civil1 Pty Ltd undertakes civil construction work, including excavation, bulk earthworks and piling works. It was engaged by Segcon Constructions Pty Ltd (Segcon) to undertake piling works, which included installing several steel reinforcement cages, at a construction site in North Wollongong.

A worker for Civil1 was a general labourer of only 6 months, with the work being undertaken at the site only his third piling job.

3 key failures leading up to the incident

  1. Neither the labourer nor Civil1’s pile rig operator held a high-risk work licence as a dogger or rigger, and the labourer was also not an authorised safety observer or spotter.
  2. None of Civil1’s workers who were on site on the day of the incident had attended a toolbox talk with Segcon personnel.
  3. Civil1’s workers weren’t given specific instructions on how to install the reinforcement cages. Instead, a general system of work was determined by the pile rig operator on his first day on site. By the date of the incident, this system had been used to install approximately 20 reinforcement cages.

Incident

The pile rig operator was moving a cage into a hole that was 3.5–4 metres from the powerlines when he and the labourer heard sounds resembling welds breaking and rings sliding down the cage’s bars. The pile rig operator stopped lowering the cage, while the labourer let go of it and took a large step back. Several rings detached from the vertical rods and slid down, causing the cage to buckle, and its top to bend over and strike the 11,000-volt powerlines.

Although the labourer was no longer holding the cage when it contacted the powerlines, he felt a surge of electricity pass through his body. At the time, he was standing on wet, muddy ground next to the concrete-filled hole. The labourer was taken to hospital and discharged following examination. He was able to return to work the next day.

3 key steps the company should have taken

The Court heard that Civil1 failed to take following reasonably practicable steps to eliminate or at least minimise the risk:

  1. Arranging with Segcon to use an adequate site-specific safe work method statement (SWMS) for the piling works that specied control measures, including:
    • the use of an appropriately trained and/or qualified safety observer or spotter;
    • the identification and use of appropriate plant for the lifting and placement of cages and drilled holes, such as mobile crane or overhead tower crane;
    • the identification and use of appropriate lifting equipment to use in conjunction with a mobile crane or tower crane, in the lifting and placement of piling cages, including appropriate slings and lifting devices such as spreader bars to enable the vertical lifting of cages;
    • the provision of a lifting certificate or certificates, including a lifting diagram or diagrams, identifying the certified lifting points for the vertical lifting and installation of each length or category of piling cages to be installed.
  1. Providing adequate information and instruction to workers about the control measures specified in the SWMS.
  2. Confirming that safety instructions were adequately communicated to workers, including the adequate communication of instructions via toolbox talks.

Judgment

Civil1 pleaded guilty to breaching section 32 of the Work Health and Safety Act 2009 (NSW) by exposing workers to the risk of suffering electrocution or electric shock. The company was sentenced, with conviction, to pay a fine of $238,000. But for the plea of guilty, it would have been fined $280,000.


latest Workplace bulletin
CTA Image

Right-of-entry dispute leads Court to examine whether training is work
The Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia recently dealt with a right-of-entry dispute following two union officials holding entry permits seeking to enter a training centre to hold discussions with apprentices ...

Read more

upload in progress, 0
Subscribe to the Health & Safety Bulletin

From the experts behind the Health & Safety Handbook, the Bulletin brings you the latest work health and safety news, legal updates, case law and practical advice straight to your inbox every week.

Sending confirmation email...
Great! Now check your inbox and click the link to confirm your subscription.
Please enter a valid email address!